How to Thicken Salad Dressing

Who would not like to start a meal with a thick salad to fulfill your appetite? While it may sound good, making an appealing salad needs some tricks. A bowlful of vegetables and spices to make up a savory dish is not the end of the story. The salad should have the right color, flavor, and texture.

A salad dressing makes it makes the salad. The consistency of the salad depends on the thickness of the dressing. The denseness of the salad dressing makes it quality food. However, it is essential to know how to thicken salad dressing. Although you may have an excellent salad recipe, let us see how a thick salad dressing makes a difference.

Why Do You Need a Thick Salad Dressing?

The reasons for using thick salad dressing for a bowl of vegetable salad are obvious. One thing you want in a salad is taste. When the dressing mixes well with the vegetables, it gives you a taste of all the ingredients you apply in the dressing. Using a runny dressing would mean having vegetables and watery liquid out of a bowl. The dressing will settle in the bowl and would not look good at all.

Thick Salad Dressing

When you have a runny salad, you will not feel the connection of the salad with the dressing to give a wholesome taste. The thick dresses bind the vegetables with the dressing to give it a tangy to sour, sweet, salty flavor with a crispy texture.

So let us see some methods of thickening salad dressing to give a rich and crunchy taste to the salad.

How to Thicken Salad Dressing?

1. Rock-and-Roll Method

This method of rocking and rolling may sound funny, but it works. All you need to do is turn the bowl of dressing up and down and vertically. It is because of the globules created by the suspension of oil on shaking. The globules disperse in the liquid and the vinegar creating an emulsion, which is thick. Although the thickness is temporary, the effect remains for some time.

How to Thicken Salad Dressing

2. Thickening by Adding Ingredients

You can lengthen the thickening of the salad by adding ingredients. We will give thickening by the addition of some gelling agents.

3. Addition of Xanthan Gum or Cornstarch

Cornstarch is an excellent thickening agent. It is flavorless and mixes well with the vinegar in the salad dressing. Xanthan gum also has a similar effect.

how to thicken salad dressing with xanthan gum

Add cornstarch and xanthan gum and pour the dressing in a blender, add a little by little of the cornstarch until the dressing becomes dense. The xanthan gum applies in the same way. These agents bring a great texture to the dressing.

4. Addition of Honey, Mustard, and Garlic

The vinaigrette dressing will further undergo emulsion if you add small quantities of honey, mustard, or garlic and whisk it well. Add these substances in amounts that do not change the taste you want. Whisking manually will thicken the salad dressing to the right consistency.

how to thicken up homemade salad dressing

Dressings thickened by these agents stay a long time and event days under refrigeration.

5. Addition of Vegetables

Adding extra veggies such as cucumber and tomato adds thickness to a runny dressing. You way however drain off the extra water before addition. Vegetables are great in potato salads, as it adds minerals and vitamins to the dressing.

how to thicken salad dressing without oil

6. Thickening Egg-Based Salad Dressings

Instead of oil, you can add eggs as an emulsifying agent in a salad dressing. Eggs act as a binder and hold together the onions, potatoes, and breadcrumbs creating a thickness. Boil the eggs at low temperature before adding to the salad dressing.

how to thicken up homemade salad dressing

If you dislike the smell of egg in your dressing, use soy lecithin, which acts as a gelling agent.

The Basics of Vinaigrette Dressing

Those of you who love salad to watch your weight would like to know how to make tasty, healthy salads. Vinaigrette salads containing vinegar are one of the most favored salad dressings. The vinaigrette salads with oil and vinegar are light, low fat with a sour and tangy taste. With a variable addition of vinegar and spices, the taste changes.

Vinaigrette Dressing

The most traditional vinaigrette French salad requires 1 tablespoon of vinegar for 3 tablespoons of olive oil. If you want a more tangy taste, you can add a little more vinegar. Let us see how to make the vinaigrette, the basic component of a salad.

The ingredients are

  • Olive oil
  • Choice of your vinegar
  • Black or yellow mustard, whole or crushed
  • Honey or maple syrup
  • Small portions of garlic
  • Salt and pepper to taste

How to Make the Vinaigrette

Take all ingredients together in proportion to the quantity you want, in a large bowl if you want to whisk it manually with your hand. Otherwise, you can shake it well by placing it in a glass jar. One of the simple ways to make the emulsion is by using a blender. Blend it well to make a consistent, stable vinaigrette. It is much fresher the mayonnaise you use from the market to make the basic dressing.

Homemade Vinaigrette

How to Store Homemade Vinaigrette

Vinaigrette or homemade mayonnaise will stay for several days or weeks when kept in a refrigerator. The vinegar acts as a preservative agent and prevents spoiling. However, tightly close the lid well to prevent the entry of moisture. Further, after each use, screw the lid well and refrigerate.

How to Store Homemade Vinaigrette


Q1: What are some common ingredients I can use to thicken salad dressing?

A1: There are several ingredients you can use to thicken salad dressing, such as mayonnaise, Greek yogurt, sour cream, honey, Dijon mustard, tahini, or avocado. These ingredients add creaminess and help to thicken the dressing.

Q2: How much of the thickening ingredient should I add to the salad dressing?

A2: The amount of thickening ingredient you should add depends on your desired consistency and the recipe you’re using. Start by adding a small amount, such as a tablespoon or two, and gradually increase until you achieve the desired thickness. Remember to taste and adjust the other flavors as needed.

Q3: Can I use cornstarch or flour to thicken salad dressing?

A3: While cornstarch or flour are commonly used as thickening agents in cooking, they may not be the best options for salad dressing. These ingredients can create a starchy texture and alter the taste. It’s generally better to use creamy ingredients like mayonnaise or Greek yogurt for salad dressings.

Q4: Are there any vegan options to thicken salad dressing?

A4: Yes, there are several vegan options to thicken salad dressing. You can use plant-based mayonnaise, cashew cream, silken tofu, or blended nuts like cashews or almonds. These alternatives provide a creamy texture without using animal products.

Q5: Can I use water to thin down a dressing that has become too thick?

A5: Yes, if your salad dressing has become too thick, you can add water to thin it down. Start by adding a small amount of water, about a teaspoon at a time, and mix well. Continue adding water gradually until you reach the desired consistency. Alternatively, you can also use lemon juice, vinegar, or extra oil to adjust the thickness while adding flavor to the dressing.


With all the steps we have given, you not only know how to thicken salad dressing but also how to prepare the dressing. These are vinegar-based, so you need to make the vinaigrette first. The mayonnaise you get from the store may not satisfy you with the fresh taste. Therefore, making dressings from scratch will let you use the spices and herbs you want to add to your meal.

Thickened salad dressing with the right ingredients and vegetables, chicken, fish acts as an appetizer and an appealing food!