How To Thin Peanut Butter

Ever come across a food picture and wonder how to thin peanut butter that much perfectly? Well, the answer is– practice. Creating that absolutely thin peanut butter is all about trial and error.

But how will you know if you are following the right recipe?  Peanut butter can be termed as one of the most stubborn elements– it just won’t melt! Once you nail that process, however, you just won’t stop drooling over it. Just drizzle a bit of peanut butter on your breakfast, your main dish, or any dessert and dig in that luscious flavor- it already sounds so mouth-watering!

Now moving on to the nuts and bolts, check out our guide to ace that thinning.

How to Thin Peanut Butter: A Guide to Achieving the Perfect Consistency

Peanut butter is a beloved spread enjoyed by many, whether it’s slathered on toast, used as a dip, or added to various recipes. However, there may be instances where you find your peanut butter too thick or dense for your liking. Luckily, there are simple methods to thin peanut butter and achieve the perfect consistency. In this article, we will explore some effective techniques to make your peanut butter smoother and easier to spread.

1. Mixing with Oil:

One of the most common ways to thin peanut butter is by adding oil. Start by scooping the desired amount of peanut butter into a bowl. You can choose from various oils, such as vegetable oil, canola oil, or peanut oil, depending on your preference. Begin by adding a small amount of oil, approximately one teaspoon at a time, to the peanut butter. Use a spoon or a whisk to thoroughly mix the oil into the peanut butter until you achieve the desired consistency. Continue adding oil gradually until you reach the desired thickness.

2. Incorporating Liquid Sweeteners:

If you prefer a slightly sweeter and thinner peanut butter, incorporating liquid sweeteners can be an excellent option. Honey, maple syrup, or agave syrup are popular choices that not only add sweetness but also help in thinning the peanut butter. Start by heating the peanut butter for a few seconds in the microwave to soften it slightly. Then, add a small amount of liquid sweetener and stir well. Gradually add more sweetener until the peanut butter reaches the desired consistency. Keep in mind that this method will alter the flavor profile of the peanut butter.

3. Blending with Liquid:

Another effective technique to thin peanut butter is to blend it with a liquid. This method works well if you have a high-powered blender or food processor. Start by placing the desired amount of peanut butter in the blender or food processor. Add a liquid of your choice, such as milk (dairy or plant-based), water, or fruit juice. The amount of liquid added depends on how thin you want the peanut butter to be, so start with a small quantity and gradually increase as needed. Blend the mixture until the peanut butter becomes smooth and reaches the desired consistency.

4. Heating and Stirring:

Sometimes, all you need to do is heat your peanut butter slightly to make it more spreadable. Transfer the desired amount of peanut butter into a microwave-safe bowl or heat-resistant container. Place it in the microwave and heat it on low power in short intervals, stirring in between each interval. The gentle heat will help soften the peanut butter, making it easier to stir and spread. Be cautious not to overheat it, as peanut butter can burn easily. Continue this process until the peanut butter reaches the desired thinness.

5. Adding Liquid Ingredients during Cooking:

If you plan to use peanut butter in recipes that require cooking or baking, you can adjust the consistency during the cooking process. When making sauces, dressings, or baked goods, consider adding liquid ingredients, such as milk, water, or oil, as called for in the recipe. The heat and mixing involved in cooking will help incorporate the liquids, resulting in a thinner consistency.

Important Tips:

  • Experiment with small amounts first: When trying to thin peanut butter, it’s best to start with small quantities and gradually adjust until you achieve the desired consistency. This way, you can avoid making the peanut butter too thin.
  • Store properly: If you thin peanut butter and have some left, store it in an airtight container and keep it in the refrigerator. Thinned peanut butter may have a slightly shorter shelf life than regular peanut butter, so it’s essential to follow the

Steps to Thin Peanut Butter

easy ways to thin peanut butter

Below are 5 easy methods that you can use to thin peanut butter the right way:

i. Stove Softening Method

This comes in handy when you prepare a sauce or soup recipe. It is one of the most direct and quickest ways to thin peanut butter.

What you need is a stove, saucepan, and of course, peanut butter.

  • Step 1: Begin by pouring a required amount of your peanut butter into a small pan or saucepan. Do not turn on the heat now! You would not like your dish to have a charred taste.
  • Step 2: Gradually, set the stove on low heat to let the peanut butter melt by itself.
  • Step 3: Keep stirring so that it does not stick to the bottom of your pan. This allows even cooking. Ensure that the peanut butter turns liquid or the consistency you want.
  • Step 4: Sometimes, this extra step is needed. Whisk well to separate solids and the oily part.
  • Step 5: Unless you need it, you can move it to a container.

Tip: Avoid using high temperatures. Otherwise, instead of thinning out, your peanut butter will have a burnt texture. And this burnt peanut butter will come of no use.

Stove Softening Method

ii. Microwave Method

Every household, we believe, has microwaves that make this method suitable. Some savory dishes like spicy chicken and Satay use this melted peanut butter to taste better by tenfold.

However, it requires special tricks. To turn it into a liquid, you need to calculate the precise time. Let’s check the necessary steps needed for using the microwave method:

  • Step 1: Scoop the correct quantity of peanut butter inside the bowl, which is microwave-resistant. Place the bowl inside your microwave.
  • Step 2: At high temperatures, set your microwave for around 40 seconds.
  • Step 3: Take the bowl out using the kitchen gloves. Mix your peanut butter evenly for proper distribution. To provide proper consistency, repeat the steps depending on the quantity of peanut butter you intend to melt!

If your results do not feel satisfactory, continue to adjust the temperature once more. Each time you give it a try, 30-40 seconds is a decent time limit.

Microwave Method

iii. Whisk Method

If you are someone who wants to avoid the heat, the whisking method is a safe gateway for you. When it comes to what you need, strong arms are a plus point! Apart from that, you would require a medium-sized bowl and a whisk.

Now moving on to the steps:

  • Step 1: Take your desired quantity of peanut butter into a mixing bowl and whisk.
  • Step 2: Utilizing the full strength of your arm, whisk like it’s your only way to save the world from eternal doom.
  • Step 3: If you plan to make some dessert using the thin peanut butter, you will definitely require using other ingredients! You can, therefore, add the required amount of milk or water to dilute the peanut butter, making it very easy to whisk.
  • Step 4: Set your whisked thin peanut butter aside or repeat whisking using the other items you require.

For making cookies or decorating cookies, this is a convenient way to thin peanut butter. With some strong arms, this can be done in a jiffy!

Whisk Method

iv. Blending Method

Having trouble thinning the thick peanut butter? The blending method is a surefire method to work wonders and thin your peanut butter.

Grab a blender, a spatula, and milk or any wet ingredient to thin your peanut butter. Check the steps:

  • Step 1: Place your needed amount of peanut butter in a blender.
  • Step 2: With 2 tablespoons of water (if it goes with your recipe, you can use milk instead) for each tablespoon of peanut butter, dilute the peanut butter. If you like a thinner consistency, you keep adding water.
  • Step 3: At a low speed, blend for 30 seconds initially. Blend till you reach the homogenous solution so that it does not remain grainy. Speed up to liquefy the homogenous peanut butter.
  • Step 4: After adding the required other items, blend again. Take it out of the blender. Serve it fresh!

For the ones who are suckers for peanut butter, add it to your smoothies to get that absolutely even and fine texture. A blender just gives your peanut butter the best consistency.

Blending Method

v. Food Processor Method

Love to clean the mess after preparing a dish? Our last method is just for you then. Although this is the fastest step to handle and thin peanut butter, it has a downside– and that is cleaning.

Let’s see how to get that wonderful drizzle in a short span.

  • Step 1: Scoop the preferred amount of peanut butter for melting in a food processor.
  • Step 2: Fasten your speed for up to 30 seconds to 1 minute.
  • Step 3: Take out some peanut butter using your spatula and check whether it has been liquefied enough. Set it aside, or you can mix it into your dish.

Food Processor Method


  1. Why would I want to thin peanut butter? Thinning peanut butter can make it easier to spread, especially if you find it too thick or dense. It can also be useful when incorporating peanut butter into recipes that require a smoother texture, such as sauces or dressings.
  2. What kind of oil should I use to thin peanut butter? You can use various oils to thin peanut butter, such as vegetable oil, canola oil, or peanut oil. Choose an oil that has a neutral flavor or complements the taste of peanut butter, based on your preference.
  3. How much oil or liquid should I add to the peanut butter? The amount of oil or liquid to add depends on personal preference and desired consistency. Start by adding small amounts, such as a teaspoon at a time, and gradually increase until you achieve the desired thickness. Remember to mix well and assess the consistency before adding more.
  4. Will adding liquid sweeteners change the flavor of peanut butter? Yes, adding liquid sweeteners like honey, maple syrup, or agave syrup will alter the flavor of the peanut butter, making it slightly sweeter. Consider this when deciding to incorporate sweeteners and adjust the amount according to your taste preferences.
  5. Is it safe to heat peanut butter in the microwave? Yes, it is safe to heat peanut butter in the microwave, but caution should be exercised to avoid overheating. Use low power settings and heat in short intervals, stirring in between each interval to prevent burning. Pay attention to the consistency and stop heating once the desired texture is achieved.

Remember, the methods mentioned above are suggestions, and the amount of oil, liquid, or heat required may vary based on personal preference and the specific brand or type of peanut butter being used. Start with small adjustments, experiment, and find the perfect consistency that suits your needs and taste preferences.

Final Words

In conclusion, achieving the perfect consistency for your peanut butter is easily achievable through simple methods. Whether you choose to add oil, incorporate liquid sweeteners, blend with a liquid, heat and stir, or adjust during the cooking process, there are various options to suit your preferences. By experimenting with small quantities and gradually adjusting, you can find the ideal thinness that makes your peanut butter easier to spread or enhances its application in recipes. Remember to store any thinned peanut butter properly in an airtight container in the refrigerator to maintain its freshness. Enjoy the versatility of your now perfectly thinned peanut butter and savor its smooth texture and delightful taste.